Lakes in Herkimer County, New York and Surrounding Areas   1. Chub Pond        We went to Chub Pond in Oct 31, 2009 and it was aw... 2. Fulton Chain Lakes        This pleasant lake has 5 square miles of surface ... 3. Hinckley Reservoir        1 PHOTO Love it here!... 4. Mounts Creek Lake        I now moved to Texas last fall just before deer se... 5. Lake Rondaxe        Fantastic bass fishing and nice brookies trolling ... 6. Twitchell Lake        1 PHOTO My grandparents do remember the Bronell family.... Does anyone remember the Brownell family who used ... 7. Woodhull Lake        It never rains here in August... OTHER COUNTIES NEARBY Albany County        8. Fawn Lake, Albany County        9. Lawson Lake, Albany County        10. Tivoli Lake, Albany County        11. Warner Lake, Albany County Broome County        12. Beaver Lake, Broome County Chenango County        13. Lake Ludlow, Chenango County        14. Lake Petonia, Chenango County Cortland County        15. Solon Pond, Cortland County Delaware County        16. Big Pond, Delaware County        17. Columbia Lake, Delaware County        18. Tunis Lake, Delaware County Fulton County        19. Broomstick Lake, Fulton County        20. Canada Lake, Fulton County        21. Chase Lake, Fulton County        22. Indian Lake, Fulton County        23. Nine Corner Lake, Fulton County        24. Peck Lake, Fulton County        25. West Caroga Lake, Fulton County Greene County        26. Sleepy Hollow Lake, Greene County Hamilton County        27. Airdwood Lake, Hamilton County        28. Bennett Lake, Hamilton County        29. Blue Mountain Lake, Hamilton County        30. Brooktrout Lake, Hamilton County        31. Buckhorn Lake, Hamilton County        32. Bug Lake, Hamilton County        33. G Lake, Hamilton County        34. Helldiver Pond, Hamilton County        35. Raquette Lake, Hamilton County        36. Terror Lake, Hamilton County Madison County        37. Cazenovia Lake, Madison County        38. Hatch Lake, Madison County        39. Leland Pond, Madison County        40. Madison Lake, Madison County        41. Poolville Pond, Madison County        42. Torpy Pond, Madison County Montgomery County Oneida County        43. Delta Reservoir, Oneida County Onondaga County        44. Mud Pond, Onondaga County        45. Otisco Lake, Onondaga County        46. Skaneateles Lake, Onondaga County Oswego County        47. Oneida Lake, Oswego County Otsego County        48. Canadarago Lake, Otsego County        49. Goodyear Lake, Otsego County        50. Otsego Lake, Otsego County Schoharie County        51. Cobleskill Reservoir, Schoharie County Susquehanna County        52. Carmault Lake, Susquehanna County        53. Crystal Lake, Susquehanna County        54. Devils Punch Bowl, Susquehanna County        55. Fiddle Lake, Susquehanna County        56. Quaker Lake, Susquehanna County        57. Schooley Pond, Susquehanna County        58. Wrighter Lake, Susquehanna County New York Lakes Unreviewed Lakes in Herkimer County, New York Atwood Lake Baby Lake Bear Lake Big Burnt Lake Big Five Big Moose Lake Big Otter Lake Big Shallow Bisby Lakes Black Creek Lake Black Creek Reservoir Boyer Lake Brewer Lake Bubb Lake Burp Lake Butler Lake Cage Lake Canachagala Lake Cary Lake Cedar Lake Chamber Lake Lake Charlotte Clear Lake Combs Lake Cotton Lake Cranberry Lake Crooked Lake Curtis Lake Dart Lake Deep Lake Dolgeville Reservoir Lake Easka East Canada Lake Emerald Lake Evergreen Lake Falls Lake Figert Lake First Lake First Lake Fourth Lake Fourth Lake Lake Gay Gibbs Lake Gooseneck Lake Graffenburg Reservoir Gray Lake Green Lake Gregg Lake Gull Lake Gull Lake Gull Lake Hardscrabble Lake Herkimer Reservoir Hidden Lake Hitchcock Lake Honnedaga Lake Horn Lake Independence Lake Lake Kan-ac-to Klondike Reservoir Kyser Lake Lily Lake Little Crooked Lake Little Deer Lake Little Deer Lake Little Five Little Metcalf Lake Little Moose Lake Little Mudhole Little Safford Lake Little Salmon Lake Little Shallow Little Woodhull Lake Loon Lake Lyon Lake Mad Tom Lake Lake Margarite Merriam Lake Middle Branch Lake Middle Settlement Lake Mill Creek Lake Mink Lake Mirror Lake Monument Lake Moshier Reservoir Moss Lake Mountain Lake Mud Lake Mud Lake Mud Lake Negro Lake Nelson Lake Nicks Lake Norridgewock Lake North Branch North Branch Lake North Lake Okara Lakes Oven Lake Panther Lake Partlow Milldam Peaked Mountain Lake Pico Lake Raven Lake Rock Lake Rock Lake Salmon Lake Sand Lake Sand Lake Second Lake Second Lake Silver Lake Sis Lake Snyder Lake South Lake Spectacle Lake Spruce Lake Stearns Mudhole Stillwater Reservoir Stink Lake Stone Dam Lake Sunday Lake Swan Lake Tamarack Lake Tamarack Lake Lake Tamarack Lake Te-jec-na Lake Tekeni Third Lake Third Lake Threemile Vly Tied Lake Tom Kettle Lake Twin Lakes Twin Lakes Unadilla Lake Walker Lake Washbowl Weaver Lake West Lake White Lead Lake Willys Lake Witchhopple Lake Woods Lake Young Lake To submit a review of one of the lakes above please fill out the form below. The name of the lake, (and your own name if you want):