Lakes in Nantucket County, Massachusetts and Surrounding Areas   1. Gibbs Pond        Gibbs Pond is Nantucket Island's deepest pond. Its... 2. Rotten Pumpkin Pond        Rotten Pumpkin pond is a reed filled pond.... 3. Sheep Pond        This is a really funny name. Is there like sheep i... OTHER COUNTIES NEARBY Barnstable County        4. Littlefields Pond, Barnstable County        5. Spectacle Pond, Barnstable County Dukes County        6. Chilmark Pond, Dukes County Plymouth County        7. Tihonet Pond, Plymouth County        8. Widgeon Pond, Plymouth County Massachusetts Lakes Unreviewed Lakes in Nantucket County, Massachusetts Head of Hummock Peat Hole To submit a review of one of the lakes above please fill out the form below. The name of the lake, (and your own name if you want):