Horse Thief Lake   Be the first to submit input for Horse Thief Lake. If you have info on Horse Thief Lake, Black Hills, Pennington County, South Dakota please submit it here to improve this web site.          These outdoors activities are available near Horse Thief Lake.   Lakes Near Horse Thief Lake: Sheridan Lake, Pennington County, 4 miles away Bismark Lake, Custer County, 6 miles away Dalton Lake, Lawrence County, 17 miles away   Public Lands Near Horse Thief Lake: Custer State Park, South Dakota, 6 miles away Adams Homestead and Nature Preserve, South Dakota, 26 miles away Angostura Recreation Area, South Dakota, 27 miles away Mount Rushmore National Memorial, Keystone - SD, 9 miles away Jewel Cave National Monument, Custer - SD, 10 miles away Wind Cave National Park, Hot Springs - SD, 23 miles away   Marinas On or Near Horse Thief Lake: Sheridan Lake Marina, Rapid City, 5 miles away Pactola Pines Marina, Rapid City, 7 miles away   Campgrounds Near Horse Thief Lake: Horsethief Lake Campground - Black Hills National Forest, Custer, 0 miles away Kemp's Kamp, Keystone, 3 miles away Miner's Motel and RV Park, Keystone, 3 miles away Elk Haven Resort, Keystone, 3 miles away   Hotels Near Horse Thief Lake: BEST WESTERN PLUS Four Presidents Lodge, Keystone, 3 miles away Super 8 Keystone/Mt. Rushmore, Keystone, 4 miles away Keystone Boardwalk Inn and Suites, Keystone, 4 miles away Travelodge Mt. Rushmore/Keystone, Keystone, 4 miles away Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites KEYSTONE, Keystone, 4 miles away   Whitewater Near Horse Thief Lake: Battle Creek, PenningtonCounty, 8 miles away       Class III-IV(V) - 4 miles long (Harney to Hayward)