Horseshoe Lake   Be the first to submit input for Horseshoe Lake. If you have info on Horseshoe Lake, Sumter County, Alabama please submit it here to improve this web site.          These outdoors activities are available near Horseshoe Lake.   Lakes Near Horseshoe Lake: Warrior Lake, Greene County, 19 miles away   Public Lands Near Horseshoe Lake: Chickasaw State Park, Alabama, 33 miles away   Hotels Near Horseshoe Lake: Comfort Inn Livingston, Livingston, 12 miles away Americas Best Inns Eutaw, Eutaw, 15 miles away Comfort Inn Eutaw, Eutaw, 18 miles away Days Inn York, York, 21 miles away Econo Lodge Inn & Suites, Demopolis, 24 miles away